Natural and Logical Consequences – Allowing ‘Life’ to Happen

I was in a beautiful toy store with my 3.5 year old daughter last weekend. After spending some time browsing around the store, looking at different toys and objects, she found two beautiful swans that lit up, sort of like a cozy night-light, one was pink and the other was white and she obviously liked them a lot. She played with them the whole time we were in the store, so focused and peaceful, it was lovely.

When it was time to go I gave my daughter a little warning “Soon we have to go, I see you are playing with these pretty swans, you can play for five more minutes”

Ironically, I myself was looking to buy a small night-light for her bedroom so I thought I’d surprise her and buy one of the swans for her. When the five minutes were up I told her:

“We have to go now but you know what,,? I would love to buy one swan for you, which one do you want?:)”

“I want both of them…”  was her immediate answer as she held them close to her chest.

“Ahhh I see, you want both of them, they are so pretty and it’s hard to choose,,, I understand, but I will only buy one”

She struggled with the idea and soon I was running out of time with my husband and our friends already out of the store sitting down at a coffee shop across the street. I told her I could see she was having a hard time choosing and if she needed more time she could think about it over lunch. When she knew which one she wanted I would come back for one of them before we went home.

At that point she was already crying, telling me over and over that she didn’t want to go out of the store, that she wanted both swans and not just one. I calmly emphasised with her but at the same time told her confidently that it was time to go.

“We need to go now, I’m going to pick you up and help you out of the store. Here we go…”

Once outside she calmed down on her own. She happily ate lunch and ran around playing with her friend until it was time to pack up and go home. I reminded her that I was ready to go back to the store and pick up one of the swans like promised. We didn’t have much time since we were all leaving together (two families) and if she would tell me which one she wanted I would quickly go in and get it before we left the area.

But she was still not ready to make her choice, telling me that she only wanted both.

“I hear you, you really want both, you liked playing with the two of them together in the store, they are so nice! But I’m not going to buy both, you have to choose either one.”

“no,no,no mommy! I want both!…..”

And soon the taxi arrived.

“Ah, see Y, the taxi has now arrived and we need to leave. I don’t have time to go into the store anymore. The opportunity has passed sweetheart”

Confidently but calmly I had to carry my disappointed toddler, who was by that point in complete meltdown mode, into the taxi still empathising and acknowledging the loss of the two swans.

She cried and screamed, asked to go back, told me that she was ready to choose.. quickly adding she still wanted both!,,, all was expressed and all was let out. I held her calmly in the taxi and welcomed the feelings.

Letting out big feelings of loss and disappointments through a tantrum is our children’s way to essentially accept our limits and process their experience

Letting out big feelings of loss and disappointments through a tantrum is our children’s way to essentially accept our limits and process their experience. This is one way children internalise important lessons that come and go in our daily life and accepting the feelings and allowing them to pass in their own time makes the experience very valuable for them.

This afternoon I was able to allow natural consequences to play out. As parents we need to be willing to allow life to “happen” because through these real life lessons our children get a chance to learn how the world sometimes works.

Not being afraid of allowing natural consequences and then be ready to support our children through the often disappointing experience that follows is a valuable gift we can give to our children. We need to trust that they can indeed handle the big emotions that come up and allow them to go through them. So often we will unknowingly rob our children of these learning experiences. Usually driven by fear of the emotional outburst, the big reaction, the dreaded tantrum. We will then find ourselves running around, trying to meet their every need even the ones that are unreasonable to us.

Doing it right

With all of this said we still have to be careful about where we are coming from. Our own energy, our thoughts, and state of mind when following through with our limits or allowing natural consequences to play out makes a huge difference in how our children internalise these lessons, or if they will internalise them at all!

For optimal learning we need to keep few things in check:

– This is not a punishment
When we come from a place of punishment the need of wanting to “teach the lesson” in a punitive way quickly spills into the scenario and will actually take away from the actual learning experience. Children always sense where we are coming from and if we don’t keep our emotions in check and become frustrated with the behaviour or requests being made we will quickly be on the fast track to shaming and punishing.

– No judgement!
That means being mindful of our judgemental thoughts:

”She is such a brat, how can she even ask for TWO of the same toys!”.

“I just bought her toy last week and now this!!”

“Can she just STOP with the whining!”

“She’s throwing a fit in the middle of the store, right after I tell her that I’m actually willing to buy one toy for her, how ungrateful of her!”.

It can be hard not to get caught up in judgmental thoughts. We need to be ready to reframe and force our selves to see the world with our children’s eyes. Empathy is significant for the elimination of judgment so acknowledging feelings and showing empathy will usually keep us on the safe side.

– Don’t rub it in
 To make the most of a lesson that comes from natural consequences we have to be extra careful not to  “rub it in”. This is how shame usually creeps in and quickly ruins the beauty and fairness of a natural consequence.
When we add shame to the mix our children will often feel resentful of the lesson – and us. Shame predominantly creates either of two feelings (often it is a mixture of both). Firstly shame can lead a child to internalise the belief that they are indeed “bad” and secondly shame creates feelings of unfairness that will often lead to wanting to push back and become more likely to dig their heals in.

Try to steer away from:

“yeah, see??? this is what happens when you can’t make up your mind!”

“I WAS indeed ready to buy you one toy, but because of your actions now you get NO toy”…

Children don’t need us to explain the consequences to them. They will get it, they will feel it, they will understand in their own powerful way, they will internalise it and they will learn from it.

Being neutral is key

It is a challenge for every one of us to allow a sequence of consequences to play out neutrally, hold a limit empathically but confidently, try not to take over or interfere with the experience and keeping our own emotions out of it.

It takes practice but it is so worth it. Not only will our children learn so much more from the experience but ourselves as well!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More posts